|
Ask The Expert with Dr. Roberts was held on Tuesday, June 26. Dr. Roberts is the author of 'How to Keep from Breaking Your Heart - What Every Woman Needs to Know About Cardiovascular Disease' and has been a presenter at Speaking of Women's Health conferences. |
Regards,
Lisa Turner
Online Editor
1. Question - What changes should I make to my diet to reduce my risk of developing heart trouble?
I keep hearing about good fats and bad fats. Can you explain the difference and tell me know how much good fat should be in my diet each day and which foods contain good fats?
Confusion about food labels is high. What is the single best indicator on a food label that I should seek to select heart-healthy foods?
Dr. Roberts: A heart healthy diet is a plant-based diet. To reduce your risk of developing heart disease you need to eat a variety of colorful fruits and vegetables, whole grains, and legumes (beans). You need to treat meat as a condiment, not an entrée. And remember, chicken is meat! I would suggest having meat at most once or twice a week. You can obtain all the protein you need from eggs, whole grains, legumes and sea food.
You should consume only dairy products made with skim or 1% milk and olive oil should be your main source of fat calories (more about fats below). Unless you have a history of alcohol abuse, one glass of (preferably red) wine a day may also lower your risk of heart disease.
You need to incorporate heart healthy fats in your diet. For many years fats have had a bad reputation, mainly because we Americans consume far too many of them, and choose the most unhealthy forms, saturated and trans fats, rather than the healthy fats, monounsaturated fats and omega-3 polyunsaturated fats. The food choices described above comprise the Mediterranean diet, which has been shown to be the healthiest diet in the world, based on many scientifically valid studies dating back to the 1950’s.
Saturated fats are animal fats, and they raise the level of cholesterol in the blood, particularly LDL cholesterol, more than eating pure cholesterol does. The only vegetable fats that are high in saturated fats are palm oil and coconut oil.
You need to read food labels and avoid anything that says it contains "partially hydrogenated vegetable oils." These so-called "trans fats" lower the level of good or HDL cholesterol and raise the level of bad or LDL cholesterol, just what you don’t want. Congress allows food companies to label their products "0 trans fats" if they contain less than a half a gram per serving. But if you eat several servings, you will be taking in a significant amount of these dangerous fats.
Monounsaturated fats raise the level of HDL "good" cholesterol. High levels of HDL cholesterol (over 60 mg/dl) actually protect you from developing cardiovascular disease (CVD) and low levels of HDL cholesterol (less than 50 mg/dl in women or 40 mg/dl in men) are a very strong risk factor for developing CVD. Olive oil and canola oil are good sources of monounsaturated fats but extra virgin olive oil has more phytochemicals, substances found in plants that have anti-inflammatory and anti-oxidant effects, than canola oil, so olive oil is a healthier choice. Your aim should be to take in two to three tablespoons of monounsaturated fats a day.
Omega-3 polyunsaturated fats are found in fatty fish, walnuts, flax seeds and canola oil. Consuming fish-derived omega-3 fats appears to protect against sudden cardiac death, and in doses of 3 to 4 grams a day, omega-3 fats lower another blood fat called triglycerides. Triglycerides, when they are elevated, increase the risk of CVD. Omega-3 fats are also important for the healthy development of brain tissue in the fetus. A recent British study suggested that skimping on seafood during pregnancy may lead to developmental problems during childhood. However there is a warning about seafood that women who are pregnant, or may become pregnant need to be aware of. Women who are pregnant should avoid swordfish, king mackerel and shark. This warning comes from the fact that some fish contain high levels of mercury, which can cause severe damage to the nervous system, particularly of a fetus. Mercury contamination of ocean fish mainly occurs in the large fish at the top of the food chain, such as those mentioned above. Smaller ocean fish like cod, salmon, and herring do not in general pose a risk of mercury contamination. The American Heart Association recommends that you consume fish like salmon, herring or trout at least twice a week.
In my opinion the best single indicator on a food label to look for is the absence of any partially hydrogenated vegetable oil.
2. Question: One of the heart attack symptoms women experience is flu-like symptoms. Should I run to the doctor every time I feel flu-like symptoms? Is there a difference between flu-like symptoms related to a heart attack and just a case of the flu?
Dr. Roberts: The usual symptoms of influenza (flu) are sore throat and/or cough accompanied by fever, headache, muscle aches, and weakness. Cough and sore throat would be unusual with a heart attack, although the pain of a heart attack may be felt in the neck rather than the chest. In addition, the fever with flu is often quite high, whereas with a heart attack fever is absent or mild.
It is true that women have more "atypical" symptoms with a heart attack than men do. (Because what happens to men is considered "typical"!) The typical symptoms of heart attack are crushing sub-sternal (under the breast bone) chest pain accompanied by sweating, shortness of breath and a feeling of impending doom. Women are more apt than men to have a "silent" heart attack, that is, one with no pain at all. But even in a silent heart attack, women usually experience shortness of breath. They may have pain in unusual locations such as the shoulders, back, jaw, wrist, upper abdomen or arms. They will often have felt unusually fatigued for weeks before, and may experience marked nausea and vomiting with a heart attack.
You need to know your own level of risk. If you are under the age of 55, exercise regularly, are not obese, have never smoked, do not have diabetes, high blood pressure, unhealthy cholesterol/triglyceride levels, or a family history of premature coronary artery disease, then you have a very low risk of having a heart attack. On the other hand if you have a lot of risk factors you need to be concerned whenever you have any of the symptoms mentioned above.
3. Question - I read that wine can be good for my heart. Is there a specific kind of wine that is best and how much should I drink each day?
Dr. Roberts: See answer to question 1 above.
4. Question: I’m 32 and I recently quit smoking after 20 years. I know that smoking can increase my risk for heart disease. Now that I have quit smoking, will my risk factors decrease?
Dr. Roberts: Congratulations on quitting smoking!!!! You should be proud of yourself. Yes, the good news is that by quitting smoking you have lowered your risk of heart and vascular disease. Women who smoke 1 to 4 cigarettes a day double their risk of a heart attack. However, women who quit lower their risk of dying of CVD by 24%, with the risk approaching that of non-smoking women within 3 to 5 years. This occurs no matter how much or how long you have smoked or the age at which you stop.
More good news: stopping smoking raises your level of HDL cholesterol and increases the oxygen carrying capacity of the blood.
Once again, congratulations on kicking your nicotine habit!
Updated 6:17 pm EDT
5. Question: My 40th birthday is quickly approaching, and I've decided to commit to a healthier lifestyle. I have not participated in any sports or exercise programs for more than 15 years. Should I see a doctor to have my heart checked before I start becoming physically active again?
Dr. Roberts: That’s a good question and the answer depends on your level of risk. If you have no or only one risk factor for CVD (the major risk factors are age over 55 for women, family history of premature heart disease, {under the age of 55 in a male first degree relative or under 65 in a female first degree relative} unhealthy cholesterol/triglyceride levels, smoking, high blood pressure, diabetes, obesity, and sedentary life style) and you have not been diagnosed with heart disease, you can begin a graded program of physical exercise without having any cardiac testing. However, if you have 2 or more risk factors you should speak to your doctor. He or she might decide to get an exercise stress test to be certain you can exercise safely.
6. Question: Could you speak about the best and worst foods to control high cholesterol? Which foods support a healthy heart?
Dr. Roberts: See the answer to question 1.
7. Question - What is the normal range for blood pressure? Is the top number as important as the bottom number?
Dr. Roberts: Normal blood pressure is defined as less than 130/85. Both numbers are equally important.
8. Question - I have recently quit smoking by using nicotine patches. Is my risk of developing heart disease less now that I'm using patches instead of cigarettes?
Dr. Roberts: Yes, see answer to question 4. You should know that just using patches, without being in a formal smoking cessation program is unlikely to lead to success in quitting permanently. I would urge anyone wanting to quit cigarettes to check with their physician or local hospital to find out about smoking cessation programs in their area. Nicotine addiction is a powerful one and most people can’t kick addictions on their own.
9. Question - Am I at high risk for developing heart related problems if I take birth control pills?
Dr. Roberts: Not unless you smoke, and then you increase your risk of heart attack many fold by using oral contraceptives. Rarely, birth control pills can cause a woman to develop high blood pressure. This occurs about 41 times out of every 10,000 person-years of observation. (In other words, if 10,000 women take oral contraceptives for one year 41 will develop high blood pressure during that time.)
10. Question - I am 52 y/o and into my 2nd year of menopause. Last week, I was notified that my EKG was abnormal. My doctor showed me a small area on the test that was signaling down when it should have been up. I have a 2 year history of high blood pressure and have been on medication for that period of time. I also used to smoke. Is there anything that can be done to obtain a normal EKG again? What can I do to prevent further abnormalities?
Dr. Roberts: It’s difficult to answer this question without knowing what the specific abnormality on the EKG is. However, this change may be permanent or it may be transient. Only time will tell. The important thing is that your high blood pressure be treated and controlled, and that any other risk factors you have be addressed. Sometimes, something as simple as hyperventilating can cause an EKG to look abnormal, so I would not become fixated on this finding.
11. Question - How does aspirin help to maintain a healthy heart? Isn’t aspirin taken for pain? Should I take aspirin to help avoid a heart attack? If so, how many aspirins and how often?
Dr. Roberts: Aspirin makes the blood less likely to clot and fights inflammation. Both of these effects help maintain heart health. Most heart attacks are caused by rupture of a plaque in a coronary artery. When the plaque material comes in contact with blood, a clot often forms and if the clots totally interrupts blood flow in the artery, the heart muscle down stream dies because its blood supply has been cut off. Inflamed plaques are more apt to rupture than plaques that have less inflammation. All women with diagnosed CVD should take low dose (81 mg a day) aspirin. In women who don’t have CVD, low dose aspirin lowers the risk of stroke but not heart attack - until age 65
– in healthy women 65 or older aspirin lowers the risk of both heart attack and stroke. Even a lower dose, such as 81 mg every other day is protective against cardiovascular events. But speak to your doctor to be sure that it is safe for you to take aspirin.12. Question - Would you recommend that I get a heart saver ct. if I have high blood pressure and a family history of heart disease? Also, does the scan show if your arteries are clogged? If not, what tests would show clogged arteries?
Dr. Roberts: These CT tests determine the amount of calcium in your coronary arteries and higher scores are associated with higher risk. However, if you have high blood pressure and a family history, we already know that you are at increased risk and you should concentrate on getting your blood pressure controlled and treating any other risk factors you might have. You need to be sure your cholesterol numbers are healthy, that you are not diabetic and you need to maintain a normal body weight, eat a heart healthy diet and exercise regularly.
The CT does not tell you how narrowed your arteries are, just how much calcium is in them. The degree of blockage is determined by an invasive test called cardiac catheterization with coronary angiogram, but if you are not having symptoms that cannot be controlled medically this test is usually not indicated.
13. Question - Hopefully just a quick, easy question.
My blood pressure has always been very low. I changed GP's (general practice physician) and when they took my blood pressure it was 140 which to me was very high - 112 to 114 would be normal for me. I have been checking it from time to time and it does vary - hasn't been 140 though. When should I be concerned?
Dr. Roberts: If your blood pressure is consistently more than 130/85 you should be concerned. As a first step, cut down on the salt in the diet and increase your intake of fruits and vegetables. If that doesn’t do the trick you may need medication.
14. Question - I feel my heart beating irregularly at times. Is this due to an irregular heart beat or heart palpitations? What should I do when my heart starts racing? What causes change in heart rhythm? What can I do to prevent irregular heart beat patterns?
Dr. Roberts: Palpitations are a feeling of the heart beating irregularly or more strongly than normal. This symptom is usually caused by premature heart beats, occurring sooner than expected. In the absence of diagnosed heart disease, extra beats are not dangerous. If your heart is racing, and you feel faint or weak, or have chest discomfort or shortness of breath, call 911. It can be an abnormal heart rhythm and depending on what kind of rhythm, you might need to be treated with medication or even a procedure called ablation. However, most racing heart is just the normal response to stress. If your heart is racing and you don’t have any of the symptoms mentioned above, you may just be a little dehydrated or stressed, in which case drinking a few big glasses of water and relaxing will usually cause your heart to slow down.
There are many possible reasons for the heart rhythm to change. It’s best to talk this over with your physician.
15. Question - What is Pericarditis? Please explain its effects.
Dr. Roberts: Pericarditis is inflammation of the lining around the heart. The heart is suspended in a two layer sac called the pericardium. Pericarditis can have many causes including viral infections, bacterial infections, tumor, and heart attacks. Pericarditis usually causes sharp chest pain which is worse with taking a deep breath and worse lying down compared to sitting up. It causes characteristic changes in the EKG and sometimes an abnormal heart sound called a rub. The treatment depends on the cause.
16. Question - How important is family history of heart disease versus lifestyle changes? In other words, if my family history shows high risk patterns, can I alter my risk with a healthy lifestyle?
Dr. Roberts: We have a saying in medicine: "Genes load the gun but the environment pulls the trigger." In other words, even if you have been dealt a not so great hand from a genetic standpoint, there is a lot you can do to lower your own personal risk. A healthy life style is key, but if you still have, say, high blood pressure, despite the healthy life style, you need to be on medicine to lower your blood pressure. The same goes for if you have a familial form of high cholesterol, where even the best diet may leave you with extremely high levels of LDL. In that situation you would probably need to be on medication to lower your risk.
17. Question - What role do hormones play in heart health?
Dr. Roberts: That is a question we are still trying to determine the answer to. It’s clear that most atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease occurs in women after the age of menopause. However, how much is due to hormonal changes and how much is due to aging (which is the strongest risk factor) we can’t say. It’s true that women who have a premature menopause have an increased risk of CVD, but when premature menopause occurs naturally (that is, not surgically) it seems that these women have more cardiac risk factors than women who don’t have premature menopause. In addition, in a study of several hundred women who had surgical menopause at a young age, while they had an increased risk of developing CVD, the risk was no different in the women who had just the uterus removed compared to women who had uterus and ovaries removed. (The ovaries manufacture the reproductive hormones). My own feeling (and again, more research into this question is needed) is that estrogen has protective effects on the blood vessels of women during their reproductive years, but has adverse effects on the blood vessels of older women. In addition we know that estrogen therapy increases the risk of clots. Just as we wouldn’t dream of putting a 5 year old girl on estrogen, we shouldn’t be putting a 65 year old woman on estrogen either (at least not to lower her risk of heart disease).
Thank you Dr. Roberts for your time and insight.
Speaking of Women's Health selects the most relevant questions for experts. Experts may decline to answer questions. 'Ask The Expert' does not offer medical advice. Please refer to our Disclaimer for futher information.
Join us next month for our Ask The Expert session devoted to healthy vision. Check our home page on July 1 for details. We're looking forward to answering your questions.











